Fiction, Bi-sexual, Consensual Sex, Erotica, First Time, Incest, Non-consensual sex, Role-playing, Teen, Teen Male/Teen Females, Threesome, Virginity, Young
My girlfriend wanted to experiment with having sex in complete darkness, and I could never tell her no.
The brisk night air made me shiver as I jogged up to Mikaela's porch, taking a deep breath to steady myself as I tried the door. It was unlocked, opening easily.
“Hello! Anyone home?” I called, stepping inside. The lights were all out, her parents' car missing from the drive, all as she'd told me they would be. I listened intently, and when I heard nothing I locked the door behind me and stepped out of my shoes. Freaking high school girls! She was going to be the death of me, I swear! But I'd never been able to tell her no, and tonight was no different. There was enough street light coming in through the windows that I could make my way to the stairs without trouble, but once I headed down to her room in the basement I had to resort to feel. I knew my way well, but it was harder than I thought it would be just the same. Wall, bookcase, bookcase, more wall... empty doorway. Okay, here we go!
I pictured her room in my mind, lining myself up. She'd completely blocked the small window over her desk, turning off her computer and unplugging her clock—there was not a single bit of light anywhere! I closed the door behind me as she'd asked, making sure the darkness would stay complete, and stepped slowly forward with my hand stretched out low in front until I found the edge of her bed. I slid my hand across, finding a shapely, naked calf. My hand trailed upwards, stroking and squeezing, finding her slender, toned thigh, then her sexy, tiny little ass! She was laying on her front, her legs spread, wearing not a stitch, moaning softly into her pillow as I reached down to begin playing with her soft, waxed little lips. She was so wet already, squelching audibly as I started fingering her, bending down to softly kiss the curve of her ass, blindly finding my way to those adorable little divots at the base of her spine.
I stripped quickly and climbed up on top of her, my thick eight inch cock hard as a rock. I had to admit... as uncertain as I'd been when she'd first described this little fantasy of hers, now that we were actually doing it... this was fucking hot! I lined myself up, rubbing up and down her soft, eager little lips a few times, before slowly starting to press. She trembled and moaned as I entered her, and so did I. God, she felt tight tonight! I guess she hadn't been wrong, thinking that cutting out one sense would make all the others even more intense!
I leaned down on top of her, kissing her shoulders and neck. Her hair smelled incredible, some new shampoo maybe, something fruity and sweet. I liked it a lot, softly kissing my way through her soft, flowing red locks. We weren't supposed to speak, that was one of her rules for tonight; if I wanted to tell her how sexy she was, how much I loved her, I had to do it without words. I slipped my hands in under her chest, taking her perfect, round little B-cups firmly into my grip, squeezing nice and tight, just the way she liked! She moaned again, still hiding her face in her pillow, rocking her hips to meet my thrusts.
God, she was good! So tight, and wet, and hot! Even more than usual! We would definitely have to make this sort of darkness-play a normal part of our repertoire, after tonight! She started making the most adorable little gasps as I finally worked myself all the way inside, her pussy clenching tightly around my cock every time my hips pressed down into her ass, grinding her into the mattress.
She squealed as she came, biting her pillow, kicking and fighting beneath me, reflexively trying to get away. She didn't always do that, but I loved it when she did! I pinned her down hard, tightening my grip on her tits, fucking her harder and faster as I carried her through her orgasm and out the other side.
She was gasping desperately into her pillow now, whimpering sweetly. I grinned wickedly to myself. Mickie had always been quick and easy to cum, that was one of the things I loved most about her—but that one had arrived even faster than normal! I kissed my way back and forth across her neck through her hair, maintaining my new pace, giving it to her hard and deep! This was going to be fun!
It was only a couple of minutes before she started cumming again, letting out a full-throated scream this time, barely muffled by her pillow. It was a good thing her parents were out of town, that's all I had to say! They were great, really, I liked them a lot, and they knew she and I were having sex... but there's a difference between knowing a thing, and having to hear it for yourself! I absolutely loved actually getting to hear her scream for me for once, even if she was still reflexively burying her face into her pillow while she did it!
Three was pretty much like two, only with a bit more kicking and grasping at her sheets, trying more desperately to get away. Four, though, was completely different—she'd given up trying to escape, trembling like she was having a seizure, whimpering piteously as I had my way with her juicy, squelching little pussy! I could hardly wait until she let me turn the lights back on—I bet she was covered halfway down her thighs! And five... five was special, tying for our personal best! She screamed into her pillow again, her tight little pussy clenching down on me so hard it was almost painful! She started to cry... sobbing, really; huge, racking gasps shaking her body! It worried me at first, she'd never done that before, not like that... but she knew our safeword, and she had been very, very clear about what she wanted for tonight; I couldn't stop, not if she was choosing not to use it. I kissed her neck as reassuringly as I knew how, and started giving it to her with everything I had! She moaned and whimpered, but I knew it was what she wanted; I was getting closer, and now I had to finish!
I could feel the pressure building, reflexively tightening my grip on her tits as I neared the edge. Her sobs continued unabated, totally beyond her control, but she was still rocking her hips, encouraging me to take her harder. I had to bite down hard on the urge to speak. 'God!', or 'Fuck!'... any sort of exclamation to tell her how incredible she was making me feel! I clenched my teeth in a wordless growl, my hips jerking uncontrollably, my thick, hard cock pulsing inside of her as I finally delivered my load!
She screamed and thrashed through her sobs, the huge, wet heat of my cum flooding into her forcing her yet again over the edge! I gasped and shook, pounding in hard, jet after jet of hot, potent cum flooding into her womb! It seemed to last forever, but finally I ebbed, Mickie taking about another minute or so to finish coming down from her own. We lay there, completely immobile but for our gasping; hot, sticky, and completely covered in sweat... it was perfect! I kissed her, softly and lovingly on the curve of her neck. She sighed with relief and exhaustion, the tears still coming heavily after everything I'd just put her through, but the sobs themselves quieting now.
The light flicked on, and I blinked and froze! What the... Mickie had dyed her hair black without telling me? Why would she do that? She knew how much a loved her pretty red hair! But then she turned her head to the side to look at me...
“Molls?” I gasped in shock, unable to believe it! My baby sister Molly had taken Mickie's place! What the fuck! I rolled aside, and she made the cutest little whimper of disappointment as my cock left her empty. I grabbed one of Mickie's pillows and yanked it down between us, though I don't know why I was bothering. Was I really worried she might see my dick, when I'd just finished cumming in her? Talk about locking the stable door after the horse has been stolen!
“Uhhh... hi, Jax,” she bashfully, guiltily smiled, slowly wiping the tears from her cheeks.
“Fuck me, that was hot! Even better than I thought it would be!” Mickie's soft, sultry voice, and I turned my head. She was standing naked at the door to her bathroom, one hand on the light switch she'd just hit, the other slowly fingering herself as I watched.
“What the fuck, Mickie!” I demanded.
“You remember what you said, when I first told you I was bi?” she smiled, slowly, seductively stalking towards us. “You said being with a girl still counted as cheating if I did it without you... but if I ever decided I wanted to have a threesome I could pick any girl I wanted, just as long as she was hot! Well, they don't come any hotter than this sexy little sister of yours, that's for sure!” She rolled herself into the bed on Molly's other side, running her fingers into her hair, the two of them meeting in a soft, giggling kiss on the lips as I watched. I'd never noticed before, but other than the colour of their hair and a few subtle differences in their facial features, they really did look almost identical—no wonder I hadn't been able to tell!
“I never meant my own sister!” I objected, vigorously shaking my head. “I mean... she was a virgin, for Christ's sake! Unless...”
“I am. Or, I mean... I was,” she admitted, turning back to face me, nervously biting her lip. Fuck! I couldn't believe I'd just taken my own baby sister's virginity! I never would have been so rough if I'd known! I mean... I never would have fucked her at all, of course! But I especially wouldn't have been so rough! “Why else do you think we needed to trick you? We knew you'd never agree... we didn't have any other choice! But now that you've done it already, you don't have to freak out about it anymore! You can just enjoy having me any time you like!”
“Any time...” I repeated dumbly, completely lost by what she seemed to be saying.
“I want to date you both, Jackson,” Mickie chimed in, speaking slowly and distinctly, like she was talking to somebody with a brain injury or something. Which, come to think of it, might not have been too far from the truth at the moment. “I've been doing the whole cock-only thing ever since we started dating... and it's been wonderful, don't get me wrong! I love you! But... I just miss pussy, dammit! I want to start dating Molly now, too! I want your permission... and in exchange, if you agree... you get to fuck either of us, or both of us together, any time you want!”
“Seriously?” I gasped... but I couldn't deny, my cock was twitching a little, just thinking about it. “This can't really be what you want, is it Molls? I mean... you were the one who set me up with Mickie in the first place!” The two of them had been best friends ever since they'd first met. I'd always had a little crush, but it hadn't been until Molly had given me her blessing that I'd finally made a move.
“Only because I couldn't have you for myself, and wanted you to have someone good for a change!” she giggled. She twisted up onto her side to face me, grabbing the pillow I'd placed between us and tossing it aside. “But... that isn't exactly true any more, not if you agree.” She bit her lip, reaching up to run her fingers through my hair... she leaned in, kissing me straight on my mouth! I gasped into her lips in surprise! But she was just so lovingly, patiently persistent, I couldn't help but start kissing her back. I didn't even resist when she slipped her tongue into my mouth, wrapping her in my arms and holding her tight.
“I love you, Jax!” she breathed into my lips. “And I really, really like Mickie, too! I want to be with you both!”
“I love you, Molls!” I closed my eyes and moaned. It was true, dammit! She was my sister, of course I loved her... but I wasn't entirely oblivious! Maybe it had taken the sexual equivalent of being hit by a bus to point it out to me, but now that I'd recognized the similarities between them, I couldn't deny that it was true; part of the reason I loved Mickie so much was because she reminded me of my sister. Not just physically, either—I'd never let myself realize it, but all the things I loved best about Mickie, I'd learned to love by seeing them in Molly, first!
“Now that we finally have that settled...” Mickie laughed, leaning in from behind to kiss Molly's neck. “Lay on your back and slide up the bed a bit! It's been so long since I've gotten to taste one, and I am absolutely dying to eat your brothers cum out of your pretty little pink pussy!”
“Okay,” Molly giggled shyly, and moved to do as she'd been asked. I moved up as well. I was recovering pretty quickly, but I wasn't there yet; I wanted more of Molly's kisses, to get me the rest of the way!
We went long into the night, fucking each other in just about every permutation and position any of us could imagine. Molly was a very nervous little pussy-licker at first, but after a few tips and letting her watch from up close as I showed her how it was done, Mickie assured her she was doing great. I came in them two times each, plus once more after a shared blow job when they took it all over their pretty little faces and tits, before we climbed into the shower together to wash up and get ready for bed. Mickie pulled the covering from her window so we'd be able to see a little after we turned out the light, and she, as the architect of our little endeavor, got to enjoy our first night as a throuple being squished in the middle. I cuddled up tight behind her, she and Molly facing each other and softly making out, while I draped my arm over top of them both, holding us all close by my grip on my sister's cute little ass.
“I do have just one little request,” Mickie purred. “Obviously, with you two living in the same house together until we're all ready to move out and get a place of our own, you're going to be having a lot of sex without me. Which is totally cool, that's what I want! I never would have suggested this in the first place if I wasn't totally okay with that! I just... I'd really like it if you make sure you tell me all about it, after you do.”
“You want that, do you?” I grinned wickedly, gently nibbling on her earlobe the way she loved. “You want to hear about me fucking my sexy little baby sister? Filling her tight, wet little pussy with my hot, incestuous cum?”
“So much!” she breathed, trembling in our arms. “Almost as much as I love watching it in person! Honestly... I never would have believed it was possible, before tonight, but I think I might actually enjoy watching you fucking her even more than I do getting fucked myself!”
We all laughed, and I squeezed them tighter together under my arm. I had to be crazy... but fuck it! Molly clearly knew what she wanted. And God help me, but I wanted it now, too! We'd have to make sure no one else ever found out, but honestly, that wouldn't even be all that hard; the two of them had been best friends for ages, nobody would even look twice when the three of us started hanging out more. Hell, Mom and Dad would probably approve of me making the effort to include her more! And having my sister's tight, wet little pussy at my beck and call any time I wanted it, right there in my own house... fuck me, this was going to be good!
We all traded last kisses good-night, and settled exhausted and happy down to sleep. I wondered... I knew Mickie wanted kids, after I finished university we'd gotten ourselves established. Molly had always wanted them, too. Would that change, now that the guy she'd be having them with was her own brother? I hoped not. Thinking of filling my sister's tight, sweet little pussy, and how sexy she'd look with her skinny little belly swelling with my child... I'd give her as many as she wanted! That's what I was thinking of, as I faded away to sleep; a whole passel of dark and red-headed little rug rats running around underfoot, my two beautiful, perfect girls snuggling up against my sides under my arms as we watched them play. A perfect dream... and an even better reality!